It’s no secret I love all things dark – horror, thrillers, even true crime. BUT within that love is an abiding need for smart, complex characters who have a ton of options and more than one potential destiny. I’m going to pick on one of my favorite Dark Masters, Stephen King, because I think he does this particularly well…with some exceptions.
In THE STAND Stu Redman doesn’t wear the proverbial pants in the mutually-respectful relationship he has with Frannie Goldsmith. Instead, King wrote Stu and Frannie as equals, both reliant on the other to survive. On the other hand, what was up with Nadine Cross? Born and bred to the be the Dark Man’s bride? (Patting self on back for all that alluring alliteration!) You could argue Nadine had free will, that her choice was agonizing, but when you’re moving toward a specific outcome your entire life, how do make a different choice and still be credible? I wanted to see more options for Nadine. I wanted to see Old Randy NOT use his Bad Boy Mojo Powers to sway her decision.
Ok, you know that part in APT PUPIL where Dussander starts in on the kitties and doggies? I would argue it was completely unnecessary and, in fact, gratuitous (sorry, Mr. King). By the time Todd and Dussander are in the thick of it, we know the old SS officer is dark and twisted. I really REALLY don’t need furry evidence to further prove this fact. IMO, these scenes are some of the worst I’ve skimmed in any book. Awful stuff. If you haven’t “gone there” yet and animal cruelty sticks with you (like it does with me), just don’t.
Even with the Easies King chose in the two examples above, he created some amazingly memorable characters. But you know what made Dussander and Flagg fascinating for me? It wasn’t their arrogance, though they certainly had that. It wasn’t their cruelty, though they both engaged in some really awful stuff. It was how their arrogance and cruelty destroyed them.
Here’s my point: we can use Easy Memes without becoming Easy Writers. Let’s plump our MC’s so they’re full of roundy goodness, yes? Complexify our casts, I say! Give them more to do! And can we take a hiatus on misogyny for misogyny’s sake and animal cruelty for animal cruelty’s sake? Okay? OKAY!
And let's not forget Le R's Important Words Of Wisdom: "I think that it is useful to remember that what makes crime and thriller novels compelling is not necessarily THE MOST GROSS DISMEMBERMENT EVER WITH SEXUAL TORTURES OF ALL THE LADIES...Also, NO MORE ANIMALS IN ORIFICES. I seriously do not want to read that ever again as long as I live."
Any Easies on your shit-list, friends?
Bonus: I got my rant on over at my blog today too and posted two of the MOST AWESOME VIDEOS EVER.
Even with the Easies King chose in the two examples above, he created some amazingly memorable characters. But you know what made Dussander and Flagg fascinating for me? It wasn’t their arrogance, though they certainly had that. It wasn’t their cruelty, though they both engaged in some really awful stuff. It was how their arrogance and cruelty destroyed them.
Here’s my point: we can use Easy Memes without becoming Easy Writers. Let’s plump our MC’s so they’re full of roundy goodness, yes? Complexify our casts, I say! Give them more to do! And can we take a hiatus on misogyny for misogyny’s sake and animal cruelty for animal cruelty’s sake? Okay? OKAY!
And let's not forget Le R's Important Words Of Wisdom: "I think that it is useful to remember that what makes crime and thriller novels compelling is not necessarily THE MOST GROSS DISMEMBERMENT EVER WITH SEXUAL TORTURES OF ALL THE LADIES...Also, NO MORE ANIMALS IN ORIFICES. I seriously do not want to read that ever again as long as I live."
Any Easies on your shit-list, friends?
Bonus: I got my rant on over at my blog today too and posted two of the MOST AWESOME VIDEOS EVER.

13 comments:
You've pretty much covered everything on my shit list. Fabulous post, Joann.
Complex characters - YES! In ALL genres.
This post is great!!
I completely understand why those things are on your list and I agree that they can be the "easy" way.
I think that the reason they're used with such regularity is that they most certainly evoke a visceral reaction in readers.
I think that any thing that's easy, cheap heat and done in an easy, cheap way should be flat out. I think there are legit reasons to deal with those things in literature, but they have to be well-crafted and done as part of an overall purpose.
But I think the same is true about absolutely anything. Men treating other men badly. Dogs eating cats. Baby seals clubbing hunters.
There's a little less immediate heat from those, but they're still cheap on their own.
I think not only can you do easy memes without being an easy writer; you can do complex or unique memes while and still be an easy writer.
Hmm, you do have a point ...
All the critics agree, this blog is a smash-hit!
"This insightful and provacative rant brings the goods home." - Griffin Weekly
"Insightful. Gripping. Compelling." - The Daily Greg
"A dark trip through failure that brings reader the closest to self-realization they have been in the last decade." - Glen's Critic Corner
Cheers! I agree with your excellent points, and would add that I personally feel like the writer is treating me like an ignorant sap when they employ sophomoric shockers. Like I enjoy the gratuitous, mindless, and shallow. Personally, I cannot stand slasher films for that reason (the gallons of blood must have washed away the plot).
So, cheers!
Greg - you made my day. Seriously. And I like these publications that give KC such high marks. They really seem to know what they're talking about. ;-)
Glad you guys concur! I vote for books and movies that make me think (and cringe too, but not with gratuitous violence).
super-great points here... I think it applies to all genres, though. Sloppy, lazy writing, undercooked MCs = always bad. Yes? :o)
Animals in??? Yikes. I'm glad I didn't read that book, whatever it was.
:o)
Complex characters are essential for a really good story.
I couldn't agree more!
My trifectas as well, but I'm huge on the animals. I know the realities, it's why I do what I do. But I get to hear enough horrifying true stories of torture and animal abuse in the classroom. I don't need to read them in my books or see them in my movies. GREAT post!
Post a Comment